Best Dupe for MAC Spice Lip Liner: Kiko Smart Fusion Lip Liner 532. We're a bit further off the MAC Spice lip liner with this Kiko product, but if you're looking for some kind of warm brown/peachy lip liner color, the Smart Fusion lip liner in 532 Hazelnut is a good option. It matches the Smart Fusion lipstick in 432, which is great if you 7gkx.